LoTempio P.C. Law Group
Call Us For A Free Initial Consultation 716-427-6683
LoTempio P.C. Law Group

Supreme Court to hear case involving search for stolen motorcycle

If you look under a tarp for what appears to be a motorcycle, have you searched the motorcycle? Or have you searched the tarp?

That question may be central to the appeal of a warrantless search meant to find a motorcycle that had been stolen years earlier from New York. Police in Virginia apparently spent a great deal of time and energy chasing down that motorcycle and its rider.

The case began during a routine patrol in 2013. A police officer tried to pull over an orange-and-black Suzuki motorcycle, but the rider sped away. About six week later, another officer noticed what appeared to be the same motorcycle traveling at 100 mph in a 55 mph zone -- and then speeding up to 140 mph in order to evade the officer.

That second officer got the license plate number, which led the investigation to the last person who had registered the cycle. That man admitted having sold the motorcycle to the defendant after warning him that it was stolen.

A couple of months later, the defendant was attempting to register an Acura at the DMV when he aroused suspicion. The suspicion turned out to be unfounded, but the police arrived and accused him of being the elusive motorcyclist. He denied knowing anything about the bike, but officers found a photo of it on the defendant's Facebook page -- right next to the Acura he had been trying to register.

This photo and help from an informant led the police to the defendant's home. There, officer noticed what appeared to be a motorcycle in the driveway, covered by a tarp.

At this point, there was no concrete indication that the bike was the orange-and-black Suzuki in question -- until the officer lifted the tarp and checked the bike's appearance and VIN.

The defendant was convicted of receiving stolen property and sentenced to three years in prison. He appealed that conviction to the Virginia Court of Appeals, claiming that the police should not have lifted the tarp on the man's property without first obtaining a search warrant.

Search warrants are generally required unless there is a legal exception. In this case, the appellate court ruled that the so-called "automobile exception" applied, meaning that no search warrant was required. Instead, what was required was probable cause to believe the stolen motorcycle would be found there. The automobile exception essentially allows any motor vehicle to be searched without a warrant as long as there is probable cause.

One judge dissented, claiming that it was not the motor vehicle that was searched but rather the tarp -- so the automobile exception does not apply. Yesterday, the U.S. Supreme Court agreed to hear the appeal.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
  1. Personal Injury

    A client settled their case against a homeowner for $275,000 for a fractured leg with surgery as a result of a fall from a ladder while assisting the homeowner install a second floor ladder.

  2. Wills, Trusts, Estates

    An estate received $57,500 in a wrongful death case involving a defective medical alert device.

  3. Personal Injury

    A client was injured while pulling a hamper with a defective handle which resulted in cervical herniation which then required surgery. The client settled the claim against the hamper owner for $495,000.

  4. Criminal Law

    A man was accused of aggravated animal cruelty for shooting his dog acquitted of all charges.

  5. Criminal Law

    The defense counsel asserted constitutional rights so that no charges were brought against a store owner for tax evasion.

  6. Business, Corporate and Employment Law

    We successfully collected thousands of dollars for a company on a breach of contract issue.

  7. Personal Injury

    A woman received $83,750 for a right knee injury she sustained due to the negligence of a local restaurant and bar.

  8. Criminal Law

    Our counsel successfully suppressed evidence in State Court from an improper search of a residence.

  9. Personal Injury

    A victim of a rear end accident settled with the defendant for $25,000 and then resolved a SUM claim for an additional $200,000 as a result of cervical disc herniations with a recommendation of surgery.

  10. Criminal Law

    A man was acquitted of Driving While Intoxicated and all other charges. The defense showed that the people failed to prove the operation of the motor vehicle.

  11. Criminal Law

    A Niagara Falls resident was accused of murdering a man shot outside his home and with whom he had previous fight and was acquitted on all charges.

  12. Workers’ Compensation and Social Security Disability

    A man received a $2.4 million settlement for pain and suffering, and lost wages due to a work-related accident.

  13. Criminal Law

    A man’s charges for Aggravated Harassment were dismissed when the defense counsel moved to dismiss charges for insufficient paperwork.

  14. Personal Injury

    A man obtained a settlement of $1.8 million when he lost his wife due to the administering of the wrong prescription.

  15. Personal Injury

    A woman received $100,000 for a neck injury she sustained in a motor vehicle accident.

  16. Personal Injury

    A woman was awarded $115,000 for head and neck injuries she sustained in a motor vehicle accident.

  17. Personal Injury

    A woman received a $250,000 settlement from a slip and fall at a rental property where she injured her back.

  18. Personal Injury

    A woman received $62,000 for a neck injury she sustained due to the negligence of a commercial property owner.

Email Us For A Response

Contact Our Legal Team

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

LoTempio P.C. Law Group | Complete Counsel

LoTempio P.C. Law Group 181 Franklin Street Buffalo, NY 14202 Phone: 716-427-6683 Fax: 716-855-3437 Buffalo Law Office Map